Summer is coming, but its boys are not, our bird call going unanswered.
Where are the Mud Hens?
Not here, and, sadly, it appears they aren’t on the way, either.
With any coming deal to bring back Major League Baseball expected to be accompanied by the official cancellation of the minor league season, the prospect of the Mud Hens not playing in 2020 is beginning to sink in.
And it is a sinking feeling, as if summer itself has been called off, too.
What to do with our lost baseball souls? Good question.
For more than a century, the Mud Hens — soldered into the identity of the Glass City since 1896 — have been the city’s beacon of summertime, with the exception of two long-ago stretches.
The first was in 1914 and 1915, when the Hens moved to Cleveland as part of a preemptive plot to thwart a second major league team from setting up in the city. (The Blade even crafted the Hens’ obituary: “Passed away February 14, 1914. Funeral: Cleveland, Ohio.”)
To make a bizarre story short, Charles Somers owned both the Hens and the struggling Indians, then known as the Naps after star second baseman Nap Lajoie. He uprooted the Hens to Cleveland to have them play their home games while the Indians were on the road, meaning one of his teams always occupied League Park. The idea was there would be no opening in the suddenly baseball-saturated city for a a franchise from the rival Federal League — a new third major league in competition with the American and National Leagues.
How’d that go?
Fortunately for Toledo, not well for Somers. While he successfully fended off the short-lived Federal League, his fortunes collapsed after the 1915 season. He was forced to sell his teams, including the Hens to Roger Bresnahan, a Toledo Central High School graduate who became a Hall of Fame catcher.
Bresnahan returned the franchise to his hometown, and pro baseball remained here — by one name or another (the Toledo club was also named the Iron Men and Sox) — for the next four decades, playing on through wars, pandemics, and everything in between.
The second separation came after the 1955 season when the Toledo club moved to Wichita, Kan., after the ‘55 season.
Yet the marriage endured, the Mud Hens returning for good in 1965 after the New York Yankees moved their top minor league team from Richmond, Va., to Toledo.